Thursday, September 3, 2009

Day Four

Starting with the end, we listened to Liebestod from Tristan und Isolde by Richard Wagner. What musical elements in this marvelous piece did you notice? How did the piece make you feel? In what specific ways, does the piece represent Romanticism? It was different to jump ahead a few hundred years and suddenly discuss one piece in the Romantic period. Perhaps in the end, striving for an emotional response is what music is all about.

We began the day by jumping in the deep water of early music. Our talk was rather superficial and general, skipping through a few hundred years fairly quickly, but still informative. Becoming too detailed would prevent further necessary discussions of other great topics! We discussed monody, plainchant, plainsong, early notation, Gregorian chant, and church modes. We recited 7 of the modes in order: Ionian, Dorian, Phrygian, Lydian, and Locrian, deliberately avoiding much discussion of the hypo varieties.

A brief talk of tropes, sequences, and conductus explained how music came to be added to the Mass and how composers were needed to develop these additions. Much of the additions were born out of practical necessity to have music during the Mass. Since text was also needed with the music, eventually the motet was developed.

Spending some time on meter and rhythm, we alluded to the rhythmic modes used in sacred and secular music and then looked at how meter signatures developed. It really is a fascinating study and explains where we get the C that most people call "common" time. For an indepth understanding, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mensural_notation

Organum is an early type of polyphony that likely resulted from the overtones in a Cathedral. There are different kinds of organum and different approaches to organum including melismatic organum and free organum with varying types of motion used, syllabic, oblique, and contrary. Eventually the voices became more independent, resulting in what we know of as polyphony. Passing through French Ars Nova, the Italian Ars Nova, Trouveres, Troubadours and host of other terms related to early music, we landed on Machaut where we discussed Isorhythm. An understanding of Talea and Color is central to knowing what Isorhythm means and how it is used in music. We looked at an example of this, referencing the amazingly clever piece My end is my beginning by Machaut. I will send a pdf of this piece to you by email.

You may ask what is the value of this kind of clever approach to music? It has to do with unifying the elements of a piece. A piece of music becomes consistent within itself through its unifying elements. Otherwise we simply have a gushing of complex emotions without any consistency. Isorhythm is simply one way, albeit an excellent way, of giving a piece unity.

Another "exciting" day in music 4000. Please read the early music articles in www.lcsproductions.net. We will discuss the reading on Tuesday and then jump into some recent developments of music. See you then!









7 comments:

  1. there is one more video coming! It's been giving me some trouble though so i'll email you when it's up.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dr. Tucker, you asked us to comment on how the music made us feel; first of all it made me feel like I wish I could sing that. But there was also the feeling of soaring, of nobility, and a rich tapestry of texture.
    When you spoke concerning isorhythm, and how it was meticulously done but the listener doesn't realize that at the moment he/she is enjoying the music, it made me think of a book I just finished reading. J.R.R. Tolkein: Author of the Century is a commentary by T.A. Shippey which goes into how Tolkein constructed his writings. The level of intricate detail included in these books is incredible, and has made these books so widely popular that Tolkein can truly be called the author of the century. Yet the reader simply enjoys the story and doesn't think about the details, and can't even express all the reasons for liking the books.

    Seems to be a recurring theme in all the arts.

    Question: could serialism be akin to isorhythm? In my mind there is at least a correlation.

    Also, just FYI, any papers passed out in class could be left with Dr. G. Church for me to pick up on Fridays when I am on campus.

    Headed off to listen to some Machaut...

    Esther

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have been one of those who did not really appreciate Wagner due to his personal life, but I thoroughly enjoyed listening to the aria from Tristan und Isolde on Thursday. The music was moving and beautiful. It was dramatic without being completely over the top. The melody line was interesting to me because it looked like it wouldn't be very pretty, but would be dissonant. Listening to it, however, proved to be enjoyable.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The equal importance of the vocal line and the orchestra appealed to me...both could stand alone and be beautiful, but together they are priceless. The rich, unexpected chords leave the listener breathless. I was fascinated by the discussion on the fermata and the development of meter.
    --Olivia

    ReplyDelete
  5. I mentioned this to Dr. Tucker before. I think that perhaps this piece is too intense. I think I'm almost lost after a while. It becomes so anguised that I almost have to just let go. I think this extreme, while brilliant, is still an extreme. I think the best music had more ballance.

    -Stephen

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm with Stephen. When I first heard it it was amazing and then that day we listened to it it was eh.... I feel the same way about 'Adagio for Strings'. It's beautiful but overdone. I much prefer the 9th variation, Nimrod, of Sir Edward Elgar's Enigma Vatiations to then end of Tristan as far as emotional builds go. Thats just my personal preference though.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I. Loved. Liebestod.
    The emotion that runs through the text is intense and unfathomable to me and I think the music reflected it beautifully. It's almost too much...but the text is just that...too much anguish, grief, fear, and longing. So beautiful.

    ReplyDelete